Middletown High School Football Team Ends Legal Battle After Playoff Forfeit
Middletown High School’s football team has ended its legal fight against a Section 9 ruling that forced a forfeit of a semifinal victory. The decision concludes the squad’s first undefeated regular season since 1965, leaving players and administrators to grapple with the loss.
Middletown High School has withdrawn a petition seeking to overturn a Section 9 ruling that forced its football team to forfeit a Class AA semifinal victory, effectively ending the program’s first undefeated regular season since 1965.
The district ended its legal campaign after learning that a judge was prepared to rule against them. Prior to this development, Superintendent Amy Creeden had sought court intervention to reverse the forfeiture of the win over Valley Central, a decision the district characterized as "arbitrary and capricious."
The controversy originated from a review of semifinal game film by coaches from Newburgh Free Academy, the team Middletown was slated to face in the championship. The Newburgh coaches identified a Middletown player they had not seen previously and reported the finding to Valley Central. Valley Central’s athletic director then forwarded the issue to Section 9 for official review.
Section 9 determined that the player was ineligible because he was not listed on Middletown’s roster for three regular-season games, a requirement mandated by the league. As a result, the win over Valley Central was vacated.
Middletown officials argued that the violation stemmed from a misunderstanding with an adult and was not the fault of the student-athlete. The district noted that the player served exclusively as a kickoff specialist and participated in only eight kickoffs during the season.
The forfeiture has had a significant emotional impact on the team. Quarterback Jo Jo Royal expressed deep disappointment regarding the outcome.
"It sucks. It hurts," Royal said. "There’s so much emotions going on inside my head. I feel so bad for the seniors. I got my hopes up when I told myself not to. And now it just feels like heartbreak all over again."
The loss marks a stark contrast to the team's performance on the field, where they achieved an undefeated record before the administrative ruling intervened. The district has faced eligibility challenges in the past; in 2019, Middletown was forced to forfeit three divisional games and four total games, which resulted in missing the playoffs entirely.
With the legal petition withdrawn, the Section 9 decision stands, concluding the season for a team that had reached the semifinal round.
J.Soderberg--StDgbl